Taking the red pill*

How did I find myself here? Strange music is sounding, with a wailing falsetto singer and a powerful, thumping beat. In the semi-darkness, I can make out the shapes of bodies, moving in a way which seems somehow strangely familiar. Those jerky movements and sudden, vicious kicks; those teetering leans and wild, uncontrolled spins where both partners throw their body weight precariously backwards and cling onto each other’s forearms with desperate force — can those be the weird, misshapen offspring of what were once ganchos, boleos, volcadas and colgadas? Have I landed in the midst of a satanic ritual? My doubts begin to dissolve as the metallic tones of a familiar Malerba cut through the noisy murmur of conversation. This is tango, but not as I know it.

The couples hold each other stiffly off at arms’ length, staring down stolidly at the floor. Right from the opening bars of this lovely, heartsick ballad about a Russian gipsy, free legs are flying through the air, knees and ankles clashing as feet stretch out, searching for places to hook legs together in sudden ganchos, bone against bone. Leaders kick at their partners’ feet, legs rigid, and shove them roughly along the floor in painful-looking barridas. The contrast between the smooth, lyrical music and the rough, jerky movements makes me wince. Not one couple embraces tenderly. No one walks around the room together.

I watch as a man approaches a partner, hand outstretched in the casual insolence of assuming she will not refuse his offer of a dance. She is sitting sipping fizzy water. He pulls her firmly to her feet and the water slops a little in its glass as she places it hastily down. He immediately pulls her body forward into a dramatic 45° volcada and she paws the ground frantically with her free foot. Then, restoring her with difficulty to a vertical position, he steps deeply into her space and nudges her free leg out of his way with a thrust of one hip. They have been dancing for perhaps twenty seconds now and there has been no foreplay, no cuddling, no walking: it was straight to the rough stuff. I am trembling for her, but she seems happy, flicking up a leg now and again, seemingly at random, with obvious relish.

A small, rotund man is approaching my seat. I catch his eye and then look pointedly down at the floor. As he comes closer, I turn my head and, as he continues to loom over me, even incline my whole body slightly away from him. But he is undeterred, tapping me on the shoulder with a sharp finger. “Hey, you,” he says in clipped German, “time to dance, Missy.” Some perverse, self-destructive impulse has me on my feet and on the floor before I know it. The orchestra is now my beloved jazzy, syncopated Biagi, though no one but me seems to be aware of the change. “I love Biagi,” I confide. When he says nothing I add, “I think this is Biagi now, although there wasn’t a cortina.” He shrugs: “We’re not really big on that kind of stuff here, you know, tandas, cortinas and all that traditional shit.” He grabs me, pokes his fingers into my back, thrusts me hastily through several back steps and then proceeds to pull and prod me through a series of back ochos, ending with a sacada which sends my free leg crashing into a table leg. Deaf to my little startled squeal, he is off again, careering around the room at twice the speed of the musicians, shaking me at one point with seeming fury to try to force my leg up into a high back boleo. By this time, I am no longer listening to the Biagi, just trying to get through a polite three tracks without injury. But I cannot. After a second number, I call an end to the ordeal with a mumbled “Vielen Dank”.

He strides off to the bar, but quickly returns to hover over me menacingly. Bending down towards me, he hisses in my ear. “I am a tango teacher. Some of the dancers here are my students.” I try to disguise my horror. “You are a bad dancer, a very bad dancer.” I try not to look too pleased at what I interpret as a perverse kind of compliment.

We have changed back, seamlessly and without warning, to the strange pop music. This particular track has a very insistent bell-like repeated refrain: “Drrrring, drrrring, drrrring,” it goes.

DRRRING DRRRING DRRRING. I clutch at my alarm clock, fumbling for the off button. I am back in my own bed, in my own flat, with bright Buenos Aires sunshine streaming in from the balcony and, from my neighbour’s flat, the faint strains of the announcer on the 2×4 radio station: That was Rodolfo Biagi’s orchestra, with the voice of Jorge Ortiz, performing “Romantico Bulincito”. “Thank God,” I think, “It was just a nightmare. No such milonga exists, no such music to tango to, no such tango instructor.”

And then I spot them. The two little pills on my bedside table: one blue; one red. Take the blue pill, Terpsichoral, the blue pill, says a quiet voice in my head. I gulp it down with a swig of water and, with a shudder, open the rubbish chute and throw the red pill in.

*With thanks to the film The Matrix, which inspired this entry.

PS Here’s the kind of dancing I might have seen at the milonga, had I taken the blue pill instead:

About terpsichoral

A foreigner struggling to improve her tango in Buenos Aires.
This entry was posted in Bad dancing, Biagi, Malerba, Orchestras and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

33 Responses to Taking the red pill*

  1. Nick Stone says:

    Wonderful stuf Terpsi – again I enjoyed reading your post and this one especially made me smile !

  2. Barbara says:

    Jajajajajajjaja, brilliant!!! Can you spare a blue, please? ;)

  3. cassiel says:

    I am ashamed reading an article describing tango in Germany like this. Lately there was a discussion in my blog concerning the ideas of Mariano ‘Chicho’ Frumboli (el tangauta interview Dec. 2009). As long as I have to read about tango in germany this way, I will try to promote the “real” tango…

    Thanks for your report.

    Kind regards from Germany

    C.

    • terpsichoral says:

      Thanks for this and for the link to your blog. I have enjoyed reading your blog for a while, but didn’t really understand some of your categories, distinctions, criticisms, etc., until I experienced this. And then my eyes were opened.

  4. Greg says:

    Scarily enough your nightmare is alive and well and living in the UK in the South of England.
    Needless to say, that’s one milonga I don’t attend any more.

  5. rontango says:

    Unfortunately your nightmare is a reality in many tango communities across the US. Your description is so frighteningly real, it make me shudder. This is what tango is becoming in the US too. Traditional social tango is rarely appreciated. We have tried to maintain a traditional milonga but we cannot compete with the industrial tango mash that is spreading like a cancer. Pretty soon it may only be possible to find traditional tango in Buenos Aires. Very sad. If only they had a different name for this monster so it wouldn’t suck the air away from what is really tango.

    Ron

  6. Harry says:

    Great story, and I know that tango still is like this in some places in Germany (but not only here!). I’m happy to live in the Southwest where quite some people try to make it the classical way. But indeed, younger communities still are as you described, and unfortunately also in the real big cities (you know, the one…).
    But I just came back home from Kehl/Strasbourg where we had a wonderful three day all classical Encuentro Milonguero. You had felt comfortavle there, I’m sure.

    Harry

    • terpsichoral says:

      Thanks for this comment, Harry. I write a little about the Berlin tango scene here and here. I was selective about which milongas I attended in Berlin and had an excellent guide (I call him Peel in the blog). However, although floor craft was not always the Berliners’ strongest suit, I didn’t experience very much electronic or pop music at the Berlin milongas I visited. Actually, I think, if I remember right, there was almost none at all. (I went to Mala Junta, Cafe Dominguez, Villa Kreuzberg and Walserlinksgestrickt). They didn’t always use cortinas, but they did play traditional music, in tandas. And I didn’t see that much nuevo dancing, either. Salon is definitely flavour of the month at the moment.

      I should clarify, as well, that I have nothing whatsoever against tango nuevo or against large, flamboyant, energetic dancing of any kind: so long as it done well, motivated by a desire to interpret the music, doesn’t sacrifice a connection with the partner and is appropriate to the space available and respectful of the other dancers. These are big ifs, but this can be achieved. However, it takes practice and skill. There are many nuevo dancers in Buenos Aires I enjoy dancing with. I have a personal preference, however, for salon style (although I also enjoy dancing both nuevo and milonguero, too). For how I tentatively define these styles, see here and here. I would definitely like to try out the Encuentros Milongueros on my next visit to Europe. In the meantime, I have been enjoying the European tango marathons: see here, here and here.

      Sometimes, when people become aware that the quality of my dancing is important to me, they assume that I want to dance milonguero-style, in an unbroken close embrace, with small movements, on a crowded floor only, keeping all boleos on the ground. That’s not the case at all. I don’t mind whether the leader dances the wildest nuevo or the soberest milonguero style, whether he leads a thousand crazy moves or just walks around the room. What’s important to me is that he holds me in a soft, comfortable close embrace for as much of the time as is practicable for what he wants to lead and that his dancing comes from a genuine wish to connect with his partner and to interpret the music, the way he hears it. Aesthetics are secondary, though, to me personally, not unimportant.

      When it comes to the music, however, there I am more conservative. If I’m in the arms of a really good leader and modern music comes on, I may dance to it — in order to continue dancing with him. But I don’t enjoy it much. I don’t feel, personally, that the non-tango music I’ve heard at milongas has enough subtleties or richness of texture to challenge me as a dancer (perhaps this has to do with my own shortcomings as a listener) and, also, it’s not my music: I find it hard to connect to it emotionally. So really I prefer to dance to exclusively traditional or traditional-style tango orchestras.

  7. Che Carlito says:

    I lived the same experience in Berlin. And….even in Riga, Wroclaw and Carcovia. It seems that the eastern peoples want to have the most modern western, so they take “Nuevo”. It is a real nightmare

    Che

    • terpsichoral says:

      Nuevo is so hard to dance well. And so horrible when it’s danced badly. I see that you put it in inverted commas in your comment, which seems appropriate to me. To me, the people in my nightmare weren’t dancing nuevo. They weren’t dancing at all.

  8. Austin says:

    Any time I read somebody writing about the German tango scene from the safe position of Buenos Aires – which gives the author a great deal of authority in advance – I am overly sceptical because this authority is often misused to support a position that otherwise lacks substance. But there is no reason to be sceptic here because this is just very well observed and very precisely put. No reason to feel sorry with such guys. There is nothing more ridiculous than the mixture of ignorance and taking yourself too serious.

    • terpsichoral says:

      Thanks for your comment, Austin. I should clarify that I certainly can’t claim a great deal of authority. I have been living in Buenos Aires for five years now, which makes me a relative newcomer (there are a number of blogs written by people who are Argentine and/or have been living and dancing in BA for decades). Buenos Aires itself is also no monolith. The tango scene is huge, very varied and constantly changing. As a result, my views and opinions on tango are also constantly changing and evolving and I’m pretty open to being corrected. I often change my mind about things I thought I knew about tango. My tango — and this blog — are both very much works in progress. And I am absolutely, definitely not an authority on the German scene. I don’t know how typical the experiences I describe in my nightmare vision are. Actually, I’m hoping they are really atypical. I just describe things that happened to me and depict the various tango scenes I encounter from my personal perspective.

      • Austin says:

        Well, even if your experience is only anecdotal and not based on 100% scientific evidence, I am sure that this nightmare vision rings a bell in everybody’s head somewhere. We Germans have a tendency to enthusiatically embrace everything that is genuinely non-German, exaggerate it a 110% and declare it a dogma. Therefore your reminder that the Buenos Aires tango scene is huge and fluid and constantly changing is highly welcome: it shows that there is nothing cast in stone. And that should teach us Europeans that we should not always anxiously look to Argentina and in order to reassure ourselves that what we do is the right tango. This will probably not work. We should accept that the tango over there obviously has many different faces and they all seem to work for quite a few people, and this, in turn, could make us relax a little bit.

      • terpsichoral says:

        There are a few constants in the BA scene, one of which is that electronic/alternative music is not played at all at the vast majority of milongas. At La Viruta I have heard the occasional alternative tanda, though not often. And it used to be the practice at the gay milonga La Marshall that they would put on an electrotango as the cortina sometimes. If enough people stayed on the floor to dance to it, they would then play the entire track. Otherwise, they’d fade it out after a short time and switch to the next tanda of traditional music. But basically the DJs don’t play non-traditional music. This is because many dancers hate dancing to it (including most nuevo dancers of my acquaintance).

        I totally agree, though, that authenticity is not necessarily a value in itself. You need to find a tango which works for you. And that may mean breaking with Argentine tradition in some respects. Tango is, in any case, a broad church.

  9. Terpsi! I love your post and this genre of writing — the dream sequence. It can have more power than reality. Although I have had nightmares during waking hours with tango, they have never been in Germany. My reality has been great in Germany — with absolutely wonderful music and levels of skill. Germany’s tango scene is my dream. I love going there at least once a year.

    • terpsichoral says:

      Thank you, Mark! I’ve noticed that you have a tendency to have some rather vivid tango dreams which can be almost Coleridgean in intensity. Do you eat strong cheese before bed? ;-)

      I’m glad that not all German tango is the way it was in my nightmare.

  10. Moneypenny says:

    I really enjoyed your sharp eyed humorous review about the Berlin Tango Scene. It is like this I must admit. There are some so called Tango Teacher who are blocking your way when you like to go to the ladies bathroom because they want to discuss your misbehaviour (I refused to dance with somebody because I was a shy beginner years ago). The following dialogue scene is not a hollywood script: So called Tango Teacher: “Excuse me!” blocking the lady’s way. “Yes (a shy voice)”. “Who do you think you are? The tango teacher was asking – The shy lady with the innocent voice: “Oh I am XYZ!” The Tango Teacher furious: “Are You KIDDING me, don’t you know who I am! I am XYZ, I am famous for my music and my Tango Teaching! I used to play there and there and there…” You are unpolite and a snobby lady”! I (the shy lady) was running in the bathroom with tears. Then I had a hsyteric laughing attack in the toilet (I think everyone was thinking I am on a pill (red or blue)) and then I was furious because my eye make up was ruined and I had no mascara in my bag which was even worse than this crazy tango teacher. I see this man from time to time on Milongas here in Berlin (he is still teaching..) – he is ignoring me but I am always smiling and saying hello with lifiting my eyebrow. So the famous Berlin rudeness is unfortunately existing at the Milongas, but there are also polite gentlemen among the dancers as Peel is and even others. So next time you are here let me know.

    • terpsichoral says:

      Thanks for this, Moneypenny. I should point out, however, that this particular dream was not set in Berlin. I’m sorry to hear that such scenes are not unknown there, either. And I commiserate with you on the idiotic bully of a so-called tango instructor you describe. He definitely doesn’t sound like a man worth wasting good mascara on.

  11. Moneypenny says:

    So it is a global problem ;-) I guess? Of course it was not worth my prescious mascara tears….! Anyhow I have forgiven but not forgotten because it is a strange funny tango story…

    • terpsichoral says:

      You know, one of the things I enjoy about writing my tango blog is that when I have a terrible tango experience, while part of me might be upset/frustrated/bored or even angry another part is thinking this might make a good blog entry. Thinking about the blog helps me to retain a sense of humour sometimes.

  12. Ann Marie Posa says:

    I wonder why so many German commentators in this blog are feeling ashamed, sorry, unhappy and all sorts of other uncomfortable things about your entry, Terpsichoral. Assuming that the people who are commenting here are not the ones to blame for what you are writing about.
    Besides, it is only a story you made up, not something that really happened, perhaps not even a real nightmare you had after a dancing night in Germany. Although it might happen, of course. But at least some of us seem to agree on that it is NOT an exclusively German phenomenon.
    I’d like to repeat that there is a lot of good dancing in Germany. Thanks, tango therapist for mentioning this, too. You only have to find the right places. I can only encourage you to search further, even if it means taking the red pill. :)
    I don’t mind taking the red pill myself. On the contrary, I don’t think it’s possible for a dancer outside BsAs (perhaps even there) to discover what tango dancing really is by taking the blue one.

    • terpsichoral says:

      Thanks for this comment, Ann Marie. When it comes to national shame of any kind I agree with whoever said (I think it was Virginia Woolf but can’t find the quotation) “It is as foolish to be ashamed of one’s country as it is to be proud of it.” We don’t choose where we are from. I have danced very little in Germany and, even within that little, I found some great dancing: for example, in Berlin and at the Hamburg Tango Marathon. Some individual German dancers are some of my favourite leaders to dance with. See here, here and here. I will certainly be happy to search further in future (though I don’t spend much time in Germany).

      And yes, of course, the entry was a dream, a story I made up. Of course it was. ;-)

  13. Susanne says:

    Ann Marie I am glad that you are happy with good dancing in Germany. You are right: there are the right places to dance for everyone I found them so I am happy and I avoid going to the wrong places for me even with a red or blue pill in my pocket – which means chacun à son gôut. I think there are a lot of different opinions about “good” dancing. For some dancers it is only the quality of technique and the music. For others it is also the aspect of social dancing when they go out in a Milonga. So there will always be different opinions on what “good” dancing is. I am happy that Terpsichoral shares all “fictional or unfictional” observations with us in this blog.

  14. bill says:

    You Should read your own posts from time to time :)

    • terpsichoral says:

      Did you spot a mistake, Bill? Or is there something you objected to? Please let me know, because I’m interested in dialogue, but cryptic remarks like that one are not very helpful to me or other readers.

    • terpsichoral says:

      Ah, now I think I get it. I recently wrote that I sometimes crave a slightly greater range of golden age tracks played at milongas (i.e. a small, occasional smattering of less well-known or well-known but out-of-fashion or less frequently played tracks among the orchestras (e.g. not always playing the same four tracks in the same order in the Troilo instrumentals tanda but occasionally subbing in a different Troilo instrumental). You have clearly misinterpreted this to mean that I think music at milongas shouldn’t be played in tandas with cortinas, that you should mix orchestras and periods from track to track and alternate between tango and modern pop music. That is, of course, NOT what I meant at all.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s